hmmmm seem to not be using my composters correctly??

They do need turning more often than you have been doing. Lot of standard advice here I fear that none of it advises just leaving the pile alone.

I'd use it as it is, just fishing out anything that's still too lumpy, and putting that back in the bin, it'll be ready for next year.
I always say I'm going to turn the contents out to mix them up, and then put it back in again, but never get round to it. Tipping them out and using what's ready, before putting back what's not, seems to be my default position, nowadays   

If you have room for a third bin, try this (but you need a lot of waste to begin with.)

Fill two bins in the usual way, with a good mix of green and brown materials, if poss. The initial rot-down is fairly quick; in next to no time the volume will have reduced by half. At this point, turn the contents of both into a third bin and refill the empties. By the time the newly-refilled bins have shrunk by half again, the stuff in the 3rd bin should be pretty well-rotted and almost ready to use, leaving room to be refilled, and so on.
Granted, the method requires the availability of a goodly amount of composting waste, but it's wickedly effective, especially when the weather's good.

These 8 free ingredients will bulk out your compost bin
By Huw Richards
On YouTube may be off interest to you.
Sorry can't work out how to supply the direct link.  But the title should work. Other interesting gardening tips from him.