Ive had some dodo compost this yr , i finding the top ended priced ones are better ,typically .
I bought some J Arthur Bowers Compost - this was all I could get locally at the time (could not find Bulrush which is what I usually use). It proved to be useless for seeds so I sieved it and found all sorts of amazing things in it - plastic fruit labels, lots of hairy stuff, dessicated cat-poo, newspaper (I could actually read the Sinclair address on the coupon), a small metal flower, lots of 10mm sized twig bits. I have all this stuff in a bucket. My conclusion is that these people have a contact to take the 'garden' waste from the local council and compost it, which they then bag up and sell to us. I have no objection to using composted stuff - and commercial composters get much hotter than domestic ones, so 'kill' more pathogens. But it should be more thoroughly sieved to get rid of all this rubbish. I don't want to buy rubbish.
As I said earlier, I use Bulrush - I have no way to knowing if this is 'council' waste composted, but it has a nice texture and works for me.
As for pumpkins - don't keep the compost too moist, or too warm as the seeds will rot. Sow some more now and they will play catch up. Just buy pumpkin seeds (Jack o'Lantern are nice for Halloween) rather than expensive kits. You could also try atlantic giant for a bigger pumpkin! They can grow HUGH, but need some fiddling around with to achieve this. Just grow then as normal and they will be about 40cms round. Unless someone nicks it, they can be fun.
O