Sometimes it feels almost like a heated political debate, as if dig everywhere/no digging at all, are the only parties to choose between IYSWIM.
For me, no-dig as per CD, is an expensive way to grow (at the start at least)
It is also harder on my back wheelbarrowing loads of compost or manure, than it is to dig (or in my case just gently fork over) each bed.
It's the same as the debates about using organic or non-organic products in the garden, some people get a bee in their bonnet
about what others choose to do. It's pointless
Everybody needs to choose and do what is best/easiest for them.... as long as it's legal