Allotment Gardening Advice Help Chat

Growing => Grow Your Own => Topic started by: richrua on April 18, 2012, 23:09

Title: Carrot seed tape
Post by: richrua on April 18, 2012, 23:09
Lidl are selling a few varieties of carrot in seed tape.

I put some in today.

Anyone tried these with good results?
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: arugula on April 19, 2012, 06:28
I haven't tried them but have heard, more than once, that the results don't tend to be too good with patchy germination. Beechgrove conducted a test a couple of years agoand they weren't impressed if I recall. I posted on that in here, but can't put my hand to the post right now..
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: bigben on April 19, 2012, 08:40
I used it a few years ago and found them to be patchy. I ended up with big gaps when one or two failed to germinate. I also live near a park and the squirrels often bury/dig up nuts - when they got hold of the tape lots came up and I had to try to re bury it!
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: Weston grower on April 19, 2012, 08:56
I've tried making my own this year. Cut some strips of newspaper and stuck seeds to them with flour and water glue. They've just started to germinate.

I did it so that I didnt need to thin out as much but I suppose that the down side may be that there are some gaps.

Regards, WG  ;)
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: DD. on April 19, 2012, 09:00
I've never thinned carrots in all my years.

My 5 thumbs on each hand don't let me sow particularly thinly, but they'll gently push each other to one side.

Thinning only attracts the attention of carrot fly.
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: richrua on April 19, 2012, 12:10
I've never thinned carrots in all my years.

My 5 thumbs on each hand don't let me sow particularly thinly, but they'll gently push each other to one side.

Thinning only attracts the attention of carrot fly.

Good to know. I have only once grown a decent row of carrots.
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: andyw on April 19, 2012, 13:54
I will leave my carrots alone then, it does say on the packet to thin but this will save me the trouble.

I've never thinned carrots in all my years.

My 5 thumbs on each hand don't let me sow particularly thinly, but they'll gently push each other to one side.

Thinning only attracts the attention of carrot fly.
Title: Re: Carrot seed tape
Post by: maxyboo on April 19, 2012, 14:22
Someone gave me carrot seed tape once so I tried it but won't be buying any. I had to go along later and fill in the gaps as it was so patchy. A gimmick in my opinion.