[Jamie Butterworth]

Cant make my mind up for which one to make 

[mumofstig]

It has to be apple pie, but if you had rhubarb it would have to be crumble


mmmm got blackberries and strawberries in the freezer...what can I do?

[Ice]

Mmmmm, apple crumble with custard, sublime.

[MoreWhisky]

Crumble.

[Spana]

Pie if i have the time, crumble if it has to be quick.

[Parsnip]

I've gone for pie, but I love them both .

My mum used to make the most amasing short pastry on her pies...

Crumble is easier to make Jamie and just as good

[cob nut]

Love both pies & crumbles but usually make crumbles because it is quicker.

[tez]

crumbleall the way hm

[titch]

I'm sorry Jamie i cannot make that choice  - love them both  - but the pie has to be with puff pastry and clotted cream  :blink:and the crumble with custard

can i have both???

having said that if it was rhubarb, no contest - CRUMBLE all the way

[Jamie Butterworth]

Right then, in the end i dended up making both  , I had the timeso I went for it  and I have to say they were both gorgeous! Im going toleave voting open just to see what more people think, just being curious now, anywaythanks for any replies,keep voting 

[plum crumble]

ERRRRRRRRRRRR?

[Lewjam]

im all about the crumble.

Sweet pies are not my thing, much prefer cumbles!

[scabs]

I like Crumble.

Especially Plum.

Grrrr....

[plum crumble]

I like Crumble.

Especially Plum.

Grrrr....

HUH??

[Jamie Butterworth]

ERRRRRRRRRRRR?

? I didnt make them together as a combined pir and crumble if thats what you mean?