[fatbelly]

Hi,

Last Autumn I bought and planted a Victoria Plum tree & a Cox's Orange Pippin Tree from Thompson & Morgan. I planted both exactly as per the instructions given.

One has survived and is doing well where as the other is dead and I want T & M to replace it for me.

My problem is I forgot to label which is which. Obviously when I contact T & M they will want to know which to replace.

From the 2 photos below can you tell which is the Victoria Plum & which is the Cox's Orange Pippin Apple. The 1st 2 photos are of the tree that is healthy and growing and the 3rd is the 'dead' one. Can you help?

[Trillium]

An apple tree leaf looks like this.

And the plum is here.

They're fairly similar so compare with what you have.


Edit: Link breaking page.

[sunshineband]

The live one looks like apple --- 99% certain

Therefore the dead one is ----plum I suppose

[fatbelly]

The live one looks like apple --- 99% certain

Therefore the dead one is ----plum I suppose

Thanks Sunshine 99% seems good to me , I will contact T & M