The right length would depend on what cucumber you are growing. If it's supposed to be like the ones we usually buy in the shops, then it probably needs to grow a bit more. If you are growing a "mini" variety, then 6 or 7 inches should be fine. I only grow the shorter ones because there's only two of us, and it means that none of the cucumber is wasted. I usually cut them just before they are fully "filled out". Almost like a balloon that has a little air let out of it - not looking fit to burst, with tight, shiny skin, and not totally smooth. I find they are very tender at this stage, but can get a bit of a tough skin if left on too long. If they are as prolific as they usually are you can try them at different stages and choose the one you prefer.