Allotment Gardening Advice Help Chat

Chatting => Chatting on the Plot => Topic started by: mrs bouquet on September 21, 2018, 11:01

Title: Smart Meters
Post by: mrs bouquet on September 21, 2018, 11:01
I am not sure I fully understand this.   

My utility company wants to fit one.  I have said "NO", as I don't believe it is compulsory.  They said Ok.

But a friend says she has one, which she bought.   

I actually know that if all the lights are on and the kettle and the washing machine the meter is going to nearly fly off the wall.  So where is there an advantage for me to have one.

Can you advise me through this murky area.   Thanks   Mrs Bouquet
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: mumofstig on September 21, 2018, 11:23
I wouldn't bother tbh, as you say we know when we're using gas and electric, you only need some common sense to turn things off if you aren't using them.

I had one fitted cos I thought meter readings would be easier ( plus they offered a cheaper tariff)  but no! Often, mine doesn't communicate with the company properly so my reading still has to be done manually. Laughable really!
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: jaydig on September 21, 2018, 11:44
We find ours useful because, although we're careful with our usage, it does give us a nudge when perhaps we could put on a sweater rather than turn up the heating.  We keep an amount in mind that we know we can afford to spend each day, and make sure that where possible, we stick to it.
Everyone looks at them differently, and some people find them useful while others prefer not to have them.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: JayG on September 21, 2018, 11:58
The smart meters need to be able to connect to a mobile phone signal to send their readings, so if you live in an area with weak signals they may well not work.

Also, I have read that there have been cases where the meters can be incompatible with a new energy supplier's systems (although it would still function as a 'dumb' meter.)

Apparently the energy savings people are achieving in the real world are far lower than predicted, which is not surprising given that there will be no savings if you don't change your usage based on the information they provide (which is something you could do anyway just using common sense.)

I've not got one, and don't intend to get one unless they become compulsory - the cynic in me suggests that if the government and the energy companies are so keen for me to have one it's probably more in their interests than mine!
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: greenjay on September 21, 2018, 12:44
recently my meter stopped working, so the company came and fitted a new one. I had to stay in for him to change it. the installer moaned that we were too far out in the country and the road was very steep to get to us.  in my opinion that was their opportunity to put in a smart meter. they did not. as to collecting meter readings no mobile phone signal so no read.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: John on September 21, 2018, 13:15
There was talk about linking smart meters with smart appliances and variable charging for electricity according to supply / demand ratios. So in busy times the cost of power goes up but the freezer stops working until the price drops or temperature goes above some level.
I reckon that's a techie dream that won't work in the real world and by the time it can be done other developments will have made it unnecessary.
There are apparently now 2 types of smart meter which are incompatible and the ones that have been installed and are often installed now are effectively obsolete and will need replacing. In other words, a typical government operation.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Goosegirl on September 21, 2018, 13:22
I was emailed to say my elec company was in the area and wanted to arrange a date to fit a smart meter. I said no thanks because of all the problems I'd heard about them and it isn't compulsory anyway. We use only what we need so don't think we'd make any savings.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Aidy on September 21, 2018, 15:13
We have one, It now enables me to justify screaming at the kids for the lecky they use when NOT in their room, like tv on while they eat down stairs, they now receive a fine so its making our energy bills cheaper!!
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: John on September 21, 2018, 15:43
We have one, It now enables me to justify screaming at the kids for the lecky they use when NOT in their room, like tv on while they eat down stairs, they now receive a fine so its making our energy bills cheaper!!
Have you managed to teach them to tidy their room or shut a door? LOL - so happy to be free :)
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Lardman on September 21, 2018, 16:15
Too be avoided at all costs. There are so many negatives for the consumer with the only positive being monitoring usage. For the supplier however - the possibilities are endless and half hourly pricing based on demand is a major goal.

There will be a point where we'll be forced to upgrade but until then I'll not be having one.

Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: DanielCoffey on September 21, 2018, 16:38
The other benefit to the consumer (assuming the 3G signal allows it of course) is automated meter readings so you don't get estimated bills any more.

At the moment, "Smart" meters are just auto-reading and most have some sort of tabletop/wall gizmo that shows current usage against a target. That is about all.

It is the Smart Meter 2.0 ones that *may* allow time of use billing. The idea here is that freezers can be told "only come on at night" or that an appliance can be told "it is peak time, can you switch off for a bit please". Whether this means we need new appliances to make use of this, I have no idea. The cynical part of me says we will.

In the (very) long run, we will all be on something like Economy 10 where 'leccy costs more or less throughout the day depending on time, wind power and so on and we will be charged differently for exactly when we use it.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Growster... on September 21, 2018, 18:37
We've got to rearrange our electricity suplier in a month's time The quote we have from our supplier is about 90% higher than what we're paying now!

Isupply, (our 'provider' - ha') although a chosen change a couple of years ago have been abysmal in their trading. They kept mucking up the online readings and making excuses, but lo and behold, reduced our monthly payment to £107.00 a few months ago!

So now, they're doubling that, and I take it as a cynical ploy to wrench more cash for exactly the same 'service' we have already! Time to switch methinks, and we're on the case!

I won't want a smart meter, as I make just four calls from my mobile each year - why? Emergency only - cheaper that way!

Like said above, if the gummint want it, it's certainly a con.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Christine on September 21, 2018, 20:30
I get an email reminder each month a few days before my supplier wants the readings. I do the readings one day and submit by email, they take the direct debit the next and issue the bill on receipt of direct debit - the day after the reading. Why do I need a smart meter? I'm smart enough.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: oldgrunge on September 21, 2018, 21:00
I get an email reminder each month a few days before my supplier wants the readings. I do the readings one day and submit by email, they take the direct debit the next and issue the bill on receipt of direct debit - the day after the reading. Why do I need a smart meter? I'm smart enough.

This is just where things went wrong for us. I wanted to e mail in my readings to avoid estimated bills, trouble is, British Gas kept forgetting to e mail me. I then got an estimated bill!
After multiple complaints, decided to have a smart meter fitted. Mistake! They fitted the meter, and found there was no connection for the electricity meter. After several engineers visits, they declared they would have to fit another meter, but they couldn't do it because the box where power enters the house would have to be opened to connect another smart meter, and they couldn't do that as it was the province of Scottish Power. They handed the task to Scottish Power. That will be 2 years ago, next November, and we're still waiting! Incidentally, I can't get an answer from British Gas on the question of, if they can't change the smart meter we have, how did they fit the first one?
Sorry, rant over. Incidentally, I believe smart meters are to be fitted in all homes by 2022 - should be extremely interesting.

Edit to fix quote - Yorkie
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Yorkie on September 21, 2018, 22:13
Others have already mentioned things such as automated billing and potential ability in the future to charge according to time of day usage.

The current crop of smart meters are SMETS 1.0.  They only provide updates to the company that was supplying your fuel when they were installed, so when you move suppliers they go 'dumb' and you have to provide manual readings again.

The government had put a deadline for suppliers to stop installing SMETS 1.0 and start installing the new SMETS 2.0 meters by this summer.  That was put back a few months, I think, and is likely to slip further.  I think there is also a deadline for all houses to have been offered smart meters by 2020 (don't quote me on this).

SMETS 2.0 works differently; it communicates with a central hub via different technology (I think), so that
it is not dependent on who your supplier is.  If you move supplier, the meter doesn't change.

If you want to have a smart meter, don't bother until you can have a guarantee it will be a SMETS 2.0.

The companies are legally obliged to offer you a smart meter but you are not obliged to agree, as noted earlier in the thread.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: al78 on September 23, 2018, 21:59
I have one, and have had no problems with it so far. It is convenient not having to periodically send meter readings to my supplier, sometimes I forget to do it (if I am going through a busy period), and then have to send one after I get an estimated bill. It is also nice to see what the worst energy guzzlers are in the home, so I know what appliances to try and limit the use of.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Veg Plot 1B on September 24, 2018, 12:21
I assume the smart meter will be run on electricity which I will be expected to pay for no thanks.

Was talking to our supplier about getting meter read and they said that as pensioners we are entitled to have our meter read regularly.

Here's what used to happen meter due to be read so get an text to mobile phone that is very rarely switched on due to no signal at home, supplier has been told to remove but never happened.
Being alert I know when the bill is due so I check the meter reading and call in on the freephone number. After I have done the meter reader turns up to read the meter, tell him I have already done this ,but he insist he has to.

So now I ignore all messages to give them a meter reading & look out for meter reader to do the job which is good as it keeps him employed...Now that is smart.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Goosegirl on September 24, 2018, 13:19
At the moment I'm with Scottish Power and they regularly email me for a leccy meter reading (we don't have gas). As soon as I enter it on-line it shows the usage in my account. Whether I'll change in the future I don't know because the main ones all catch up with each other anyway.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: JayG on September 24, 2018, 13:33
My online dual fuel tariff requires me to submit my own readings at least every 3 months to keep the 'bonus' payment going, which isn't exactly a lot to ask.

Once a year (don't know if it's a statutory requirement) the meter is read by a meter reader - I suspect the main reason is to check you haven't installed some 'interesting' additional gas pipe and electrical cable work of your own!  8)
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: al78 on September 24, 2018, 16:03
I assume the smart meter will be run on electricity which I will be expected to pay for no thanks.

The amount of electricity used to power a smart meter is so small, you will not notice any increase in your bill. It is the appliances that are designed to generate heat which are the big energy guzzlers, powering a very small screen is insignificant by comparison.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Growster... on September 24, 2018, 16:41
At the moment I'm with Scottish Power and they regularly email me for a leccy meter reading (we don't have gas). As soon as I enter it on-line it shows the usage in my account. Whether I'll change in the future I don't know because the main ones all catch up with each other anyway.

Of course, you are absolutely right, Goosers!

Surprise, surprise about the suppliers, they'll all be the same but several points higher soon, even trying to tell everyone that they're 'competitive'! It's not right that the more PC challenged can't get a decent deal, but of course, they're still paying the subsidies for the huge great windmills everywhere - nobody voted for that!

(You nearly got political then Growster, watch it..;0)
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: John on September 24, 2018, 20:34
Sticking with smart meters rather than windmills :) I don't see much reason to say no to them on an individual level and I suppose it would be interesting to see the power consumption shoot up when the kettle's on.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Veg Plot 1B on September 25, 2018, 08:23
"The amount of electricity used to power a smart meter is so small, you will not notice any increase in your bill. It is the appliances that are designed to generate heat which are the big energy guzzlers, powering a very small screen is insignificant by comparison."

Yes I agree but why not have solar unit that will run it for free like the one in my calculator.
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Yorkie on September 29, 2018, 10:59
My online dual fuel tariff requires me to submit my own readings at least every 3 months to keep the 'bonus' payment going, which isn't exactly a lot to ask.

Once a year (don't know if it's a statutory requirement) the meter is read by a meter reader - I suspect the main reason is to check you haven't installed some 'interesting' additional gas pipe and electrical cable work of your own!  8)

I think you're right about the requirement to read them at certain intervals; think it could be at 2 year intervals max.  No idea if this will change post-smart meter
Title: Re: Smart Meters
Post by: Growster... on September 29, 2018, 14:58
The big fiddle is when the electricity companies deliberately confuse the issue by mixing two summers with just one winter one (18 month contract), then loading the future ones with 'projected winter' readings.

As before, they're all out to con you, forget the 'regulator', it's all a fantasy and only there to appease toothless gummint watchdogs!

I'm online for some time at the moment and getting so many quotes, it's a bit silly, but it's our pension, so at the end of the year I can honestly buy Mrs Growster a new hat on the savings!