Allotment Gardening Advice Help Chat

Growing => Grow Your Own => Topic started by: Gandan57 on July 01, 2011, 19:31

Title: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on July 01, 2011, 19:31
Set myself a little challenge in the spring, to pick the first runners by today, 1st July and be still picking in 100 days time, which I make to be 8th October.

Because of the naff weather in May and much of June things didnt look promising but I just managed to pick a small handfull for tea tonight.   

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSC00706.jpg)     

Also today to keep things going I`ve made a fifth successional sowing of a few seeds. First seeds were sown on 31st March so that is an interval of 92 days.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: LilacSandy on July 01, 2011, 19:33
I am greener than your beans.  I only have a few flowers, all together say ahh... :( :(
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sunshineband on July 01, 2011, 20:14
I am greener than your beans.  I only have a few flowers, all together say ahh... :( :(

That makes two of us  :ohmy:

But I do have pink flowers as well as red ones and white ones  :D :D :D :D

All joking aside -- those beans look lush  :)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on July 01, 2011, 20:20
Mine are still only about 3ft tall and no flowers yet *sniff sniff*
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sunshineband on July 01, 2011, 20:24
Mine are still only about 3ft tall and no flowers yet *sniff sniff*

Just pop over and you can share mine  :)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on July 01, 2011, 20:25
Awww you're sooo kind  :lol:
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on July 01, 2011, 20:26
My neighbour`s are only six feet high, yet he was picking yesterday.

I have one plant that has red and white flowers. Should have taken a pic of it.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sunshineband on July 01, 2011, 20:27
Awww you're sooo kind  :lol:

I know  :closedeyes:
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 10, 2011, 13:16
Challenge successful!

Today is day 102 since picking started and managed to fill a carrier bag, although quality and quantity are tailing off now. Still a few flowers but whether these will set beans is debatable, and these flowers are not on the last sowing, made on 1st July, but on earlier ones.         

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSCF8016.jpg) 
Photo taken this morning.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on October 10, 2011, 13:24
Well done you!
which variety are they?
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 10, 2011, 13:52
Variety unknown I`m afraid mum, my own saved seed.

I did grow a packet of Moonlight alongside my own. These germinated later and were behind mine in growth but did crop slightly earlier and finished quicker. I haven`t seen a white flower for many weeks now.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: totalnovice on October 10, 2011, 14:29
WOW! very impressive - my beans have not been as good as last years but I have still had plenty, and there are just  a few in the freezer for soups and stews in the winter. At least I won't still be eating them as the first fresh ones come off next year!

I'm very impressed with 102 days of picking though. Good going.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: azubah on October 10, 2011, 17:45
Mine were very slow to start, but produced a reasonable amount, though not as much as usual. There are still a few coming, but not many and with a tendancy to be thin. The harsh winds did a lot of damage.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: shokkyy on October 10, 2011, 19:09
My crop was a bit pathetic this year, and they were really nice beans so I'd have liked a lot more. I pulled the plants up this week, because the few remaining beans on it were all kind of withering rather than getting bigger. I didn't have enough to freeze many, but they were surprisingly nice from frozen so I'm keen to increase and extend the crop next year.

Gandan - I couldn't have come close to filling a carrier bag even at peak, and that was from 32 plants. How many plants were you getting that crop from? And when you say you did succession sowing, do you mean you started a new row alongside the old row, or you replaced the old plants?
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: ermck1 on October 10, 2011, 20:05
I have been given some very special seed for next years runners! 15 years of developing the best crop.

Fingers crossed.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 19, 2011, 20:35
Final picking today, so that`s 111 days, next year the challenge is a 120 day harvest. 

shokkyy - I used around 1.25 kilos of seed and made five sowings between 31st March and 1st July. As each seed weighs approximately 1.7 grams that`s roughly 750 seeds. The row was originally 24 feet but it had to be extended to 32 feet long, and each sowing was planted in a portion of the row. 

The first sowing was in carrier bags in large pots and tubs in the conservatory and the plants had four foot high mini wigwams to climb up until they were planted in the row in mid May. Early potatoes were grown in part of the row to maximise space, so once the first sowing were transplanted, more seeds were planted in the pots to be planted out when the spuds had been dug.   

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSC00573.jpg)     
Photo taken 1st June showing first two sowings in 16 feet of the row.       

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSC00655.jpg)     
This photo and the two below were taken mid June and show the third sowing in bags in tubs being planted out after the potatoes. The carriers were cut half way down around, placed in position and the two sides pulled away to leave the plants in situ.   

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSC00654.jpg)         

(http://i1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa363/trevor3457/DSC00653.jpg)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sunshineband on October 19, 2011, 20:37
Wow! That is some dedication to the runner bean  :D :D

I don;t think I could emulate this, but it has been  very interesting thank you  :)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on October 19, 2011, 20:55
Well done, I must admit to planting some and at the same time sowing some for later, but I'm sure I've never managed such a long season.

I'll have to try harder  ;)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 19, 2011, 21:33
Thanks for those comments.

This is the first year I`ve made a determined effort to prolong the season. 

Now I`m busy saving seed for next year as the first sowing is pencilled in for mid March, less than five months away!
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sunshineband on October 19, 2011, 21:35
Thanks for those comments.

This is the first year I`ve made a determined effort to prolong the season. 

Now I`m busy saving seed for next year as the first sowing is pencilled in for mid March, less than five months away!

 :lol: :lol: :lol:
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: shokkyy on October 19, 2011, 22:27
Oh good grief, no wonder you were picking so many :)

Much as I like runner beans, if I did that many I wouldn't have space for peas or mangetout, and I like those too. The most I could manage is about a 15' row, I should think. I'll have to try staggering the sowings a bit more than I did last year though. I only did 3 sowings about a couple of weeks apart.  The first lot didn't get sown until the second week in April and were planted out just under 3 weeks later.

How on earth did you find a piece of wood long enough to do the single supporting brace along the row? And it looks like you were planting them out in clumps rather than sticking a couple against each cane. Approx how many did you have on each cane?
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: sarajane on October 20, 2011, 07:37
Wow, very impressive.  That is what I call commitment to the humble runner bean.

I have never even thought to do more than one sowing.  I too only grow a 15 foot row but will try to do 2 sowings next year if that is the result.  Mine finished weeks ago.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 20, 2011, 20:09
The row runs north south to reduce shading, but this meant it would catch the full force of the westerly winds, so I didn`t want it to blow over. The half round rail is in eight foot lengths screwed to the tops of 5`6" stakes, and this framework will stay in place permanently. The rails were originally 12 feet long but I had to saw off four feet to get them in the car!

To this frame are lashed 8 feet long Gardman green plastic covered metal rods every four feet of the row, infilled with 8 feet canes every 12 inches with horizontal canes tied to the tops of the rods and canes. I decided on this design before I joined this forum and found out about the Munty frame.

There may have been twenty plants in each pot and six to eight plants may have had to share each cane or rod. In the end this overcrowding probably reduced yield per plant and next year I`m going to try and reduce the amount of seed, but when the seed is free that goes against the grain somewhat. :)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: shokkyy on October 20, 2011, 21:53
You've inspired me now :)

I didn't have a good crop this year at all, which I think was mostly the foul weather but also that they had too much shade from a horse chestnut (which has now been cut back) and that the soil in the bed needed some improving. But I was limiting myself to 2 plants per cane, and your experiment does seem to demonstrate that I can get away with throwing in loads more plants than that, so I will :)

Trouble is, a lot of runner beans seem to be sold in packets of about 30 to 40, which works out kind of expensive if you want to do more than one packet's worth.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on October 20, 2011, 22:17
. But I was limiting myself to 2 plants per cane, and your experiment does seem to demonstrate that I can get away with throwing in loads more plants than that, so I will :)

You'd need good soil & compost to grow them close together like Gandan  :)
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: shokkyy on October 21, 2011, 01:59

You'd need good soil & compost to grow them close together like Gandan  :)

Well, having been disappointed by my returns this year, I'm about to hit that veggie bed with every weapon at my disposal - compost, leaf mould, chicken manure pellets, seaweed meal and rock dust. Maybe I'll even manage a trench, if I can get deep enough into the bed (new bed this year and was initially so compacted that I really struggled to dig into it).
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: mumofstig on October 21, 2011, 09:45
a sound plan, if ever there was one  :lol:
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: Gandan57 on October 22, 2011, 23:05
Have you never thought of saving your own seed shokkyy? If you have an allotment you could ask other plotholders if they have any surplus runner bean pods that are drying on the plants now.

I had no plot until late summer last year and most of this year`s seed came from our site`s communal compost heap twelve months ago.

There are hundreds of pods on my row that weren`t picked when young and these are now drying to produce next year`s seed, but there will be far more than I need so if you`re passing anytime you can have some.
Title: Re: Runner Beans- the 100 Day Challenge
Post by: shokkyy on October 23, 2011, 02:07
Have you never thought of saving your own seed shokkyy? If you have an allotment you could ask other plotholders if they have any surplus runner bean pods that are drying on the plants now.

I had no plot until late summer last year and most of this year`s seed came from our site`s communal compost heap twelve months ago.

There are hundreds of pods on my row that weren`t picked when young and these are now drying to produce next year`s seed, but there will be far more than I need so if you`re passing anytime you can have some.

Yes, I have thought of it. Trouble is, when you're not getting that big a crop you can't really afford to sacrifice a portion of it for next year's seed.

I don't have an allotment, just a big garden (half an acre), which I keep sneaking more and more veggie beds into :) The bed I used for beans and peas this year is a 17 X 17 foot square, half of which was recently lawn and hence very compacted and difficult to dig. I did put a couple of inches of imported topsoil on top which I forked in as best I could, as well as plenty of BFB, but it was obvious the soil wasn't good because I kept finding toadstools growing in there but not many of the usual weeds, i.e. low nutrition and poor drainage. I only did a 7 foot row of runners, but next year I'm going to extend that to the full length of the bed because until I tasted them I'd forgotten how much I used to like runner beans. The plants seemed healthy enough but were late and didn't give a very big crop at all. I am going to do as much as I can to improve the soil as well, so hopefully next year's crop will be much bigger.

It's very kind of you to offer the seed and I'd love to take you up on that, but sadly I never get down to your area.