Pretty good for me this year... I'm growing them through weedmulch plastic as a ground clearer on a new bit I'm breaking in.... Total yield is currently at 52 including 7 pumpkins of an unknown variety....14 butternuts, 7 bon-bon buttercup, 3 uchiki-kuri, 21 Winter Festival..... I think.... one of the butternuts (a Hunter) has grown a couple more female flowers and as it had only produced one small fruit which is now ripe I'm letting it have a go and I'll protect it if I can when it gets colder... it can have a chance anyway....
Would recommend hunter over Waltham for butternuts, the hunters produce smaller fruit but apart from the runt they tend to produce several useful sized squash per plant rather than the individual monsters that the Walthams have set.
Festival is productive and fairly compact by the standards of squash. Sensible size too.
The Bon-Bon's are the Dora-the-Explorer of the squash world and mine investgated next doors plot, the potato bags, the tomato bag, the sweetcorn, swamped the Uchiki Kuri while I was away and were last seen heading off for a holiday in Cornwall... 7 big squash off two plants though maybe too big.
The Uchiki's got swamped by the Bon-Bon's and by the time I'd sorted it out they were a bit sorry for themselves but they still did two good ones and a runt....
Pumpkin isn't a giant so I'm hoping they'll taste OK. First one ripened off ages ago, the other six (including the biggest) are just finishing going orange now... biggest three are spoken for for lanterns, the smallest one will get eaten early to find out the fate of the other three, lanterns or kitchen.... Variety unknown as seed saved by sis-in-law from shop-bought halloween thing last year..
One thought.... butternuts and indeed all squashes tend to like to outbreed.. .I hand-fertilized a lot but rarely with the same variety... I don't keep squash seed so it doesn't matter....